It’s cool when a song is in 5 or even 7 but who puts a pop song in 11? Outkast that’s who. Hey Ya still kills me.
What was really fun, once upon a time in my life, was playing in a band that had simple pop compositions where I was expected to solo over indefinitely. Like until the guitarist gave me an urgent look to finish. Sometimes that took a very long time and that was fine. So the thing is, how much can you do with ordinary melodic ideas in a song in C for instance that is a loop of 2 or 3 chords. Eventually I would move into C#. It was unique and probably confusing to some, exciting to others, but that’s ok after all I just wanted to make it more interesting.
The comments on Facebook sometimes are confusing or to put it another way there are some confusing comments because they miss the point of what the thread is about. I’m thinking it would be more fun to replace the thread with something unrelated, like how to play golf. Then the comments that make no sense to me would be so much more interesting. That’s my new evil plan.
More so they do it underground in Europe. Often I don’t remember, but then I look up and I do. Many wires get the electricity into each home. Like if it didn’t exist, if someone described what that would be like, I bet afterward nobody would agree to this visual pollution. So it is. Weaving through trees, century old branches received chainsaw surgery, even empty spaces have some permanent blobs suspended between poles. What can’t I stand more, this or popular songs based on loops? 25 years of looping pedals is, to me, more interesting than the music. I presume being broke is a major part of the story, the ease of working alone vs. with a group. That’s a little bit interesting but hearing a voice go pow pow boom boom is only neat for 6 seconds but the song is 4 minutes. People hooked on novelty, like celebrating an air guitarist instead of Charlie Christian’s fingers on strings. So much American Idol aesthetic in music made with loops, bores me like all unvarying repetitions. And my students gush over these songs as though they represent top songwriting achievement. I guess it does for them but for me feels like awarding Monsanto’s new red wine because it tastes great and didn’t use real grapes.