The first person to notice something was wrong was a piano tuner in Winnipeg named Leonard Katz. Leonard had been tuning pianos for forty-three years, and he developed three convictions: most people couldn’t hear the difference between a well-tuned piano and a poorly tuned one, musicians were rarely able to pay their bills, and the government was lying about something. He wasn’t sure what.
Then one afternoon, while tuning a Yamaha upright in a church basement, he discovered that middle C was vibrating at 261.63 hertz. Exactly as it should. It struck him as suspicious. Why had the entire Western world agreed upon the frequency of middle C? Within three weeks, he’d discovered the International Organization for Standardization, the Rockefeller Foundation, and Giuseppe Verdian, an obscure musicologist who had opposed A440 because it was unnatural. Leonard started a website called The Truth About C. His argument was that standardizing musical pitch had been a deliberate attempt to manipulate human consciousness. A440 was the frequency of obedience. A432 was the frequency of liberation.
People pointed out that pitch had varied throughout history. Leonard blocked them. His website attracted thousands of followers, particularly people who believed fluoride was mind control, birds were surveillance equipment, and the Beatles had been replaced by other Beatles just before Sgt. Peppers. He sold tuning forks for $79.95. His wife, Miriam, was delighted, Leonard had never earned more money from music. One day, Leonard received an email from the jazz pianist Arthur de Forest.
“Dear Leonard, I’ve read your theories. You’re missing something. The conspiracy isn’t in the frequency. It’s in the harmony.”
Leonard called immediately.
“Western harmony,” Arthur explained, “conditions people to expect resolution. The dominant seventh creates tension. The tonic resolves it. You spend your life expecting somebody else to resolve your problems. The government. Your wife. Your therapist. God.”
“So the perfect cadence is a political instrument?”
“Exactly.”
“What about the plagal cadence?”
“Religion.”
“And the deceptive cadence?”
“Capitalism.”
Leonard invited Arthur to speak at the first International Conference on Musical Awakening, scheduled for October at a Holiday Inn near the Winnipeg airport, where the previous week’s conference had been devoted to exposing the airport’s namesake, James Richardson, as robber baron – a revelation that prompted demands to rename the airport after someone whose descendants were less likely to hire lawyers. Thirty-seven people attended, including a woman from Regina who believed the oboe was responsible for the collapse of the Soviet Union.
Arthur performed a forty-six-minute improvisation, avoiding conventional cadences. He played tone clusters and dissonant intervals. At one point he rubbed the piano strings with a raw potato. When he finished, nobody applauded. Arthur was pleased.
“See?” he told Leonard. “They’re no longer conditioned to respond.”
The conference was declared a triumph. Leonard and Arthur began touring under the title The Notes They Don’t Want You to Hear. Arthur explained how music imposed social order. Military marches taught obedience. National anthems encouraged tribal identification. Muzak discouraged independent thought. The twelve-bar blues trapped people in predictable cycles of suffering. A woman in Brandon asked if Bach was part of the conspiracy.
“Not consciously,” Arthur replied.
Standing ovation. Then, after a performance in Thunder Bay, a young woman approached Arthur.
“I enjoyed your music, but I don’t believe your conspiracy theories.”
“Why not?”
“Because everything proves you’re right. If people applaud, they’re awakening. If they don’t, they’re also awakening. There’s no evidence that could prove you wrong.”
“That’s a very conventional way of thinking.”
“Maybe. But I loved the part where you played the same note for four minutes.”
Arthur smiled.
“That was about the tyranny of repetition.”
“I thought it was about loneliness.”
Arthur didn’t know what to say. He hadn’t been thinking about loneliness. He’d been worrying about his parking meter. How could she hear something that wasn’t there? Or perhaps it was there, despite him. During a concert in Kenora, Arthur did something that nearly destroyed the movement. He played a C-major chord. Leonard was horrified. Arthur followed it with G major, then returned to C. Several audience members began crying. Leonard stormed onstage.
“What are you doing?”
“I don’t know.”
“That’s the progression we’ve spent two years warning people about!”
“I know.”
“Then why are you playing it?”
“Because I wanted to hear what happened.”
Leonard turned to the audience.
“He’s been compromised.”
Someone shouted, “CIA!”b Another shouted, “Canada Council!”
A third accused Arthur of accepting money from Big Piano. Arthur continued playing, wandering through harmonies with no destination. Eventually he stopped, simply because he felt finished. Leonard demanded an explanation. Arthur considered discussing tonal harmony, psychological conditioning, and the politics of musical standardization.
Instead he said, “I think I’ve been using the conspiracy to avoid listening.”
“What does that mean?”
“I knew what everything meant before I heard it.”
“Of course. That’s called knowledge.”
“Maybe. But it doesn’t leave much room for music.”
Leonard refused to speak to him again. He returned to Winnipeg, where he expanded his website to include the theory that jazz improvisation had been invented by the CIA to encourage moral relativism. He sold another six hundred tuning forks. Arthur continued performing. He sometimes played conventional chords and sometimes didn’t. Occasionally he performed an entire concert without touching the piano. His audiences grew smaller. His income declined. His reviews improved. One evening, after a concert outside Peterborough, an elderly man approached.
“I don’t understand that music you play.”
Arthur smiled.
“Neither do I.”
“Well, somebody ought to.”
Driving home, Arthur stopped for coffee near Oshawa. Playing over the gas station speakers was Mary Wells singing “You Beat Me to the Punch”, built around the same four chords he’d spent years identifying as instruments of psychological domination. He listened. For reasons he couldn’t explain, he found it beautiful. Perhaps it was the melody. Perhaps he was tired. He didn’t know. And for the first time, not knowing didn’t seem like evidence that somebody was hiding something.
He got into his car and turned on the radio. Someone was playing Beethoven. Arthur changed the station. A man was explaining how the moon landing had been faked. Arthur turned up the volume. Not because he believed him. Because he no longer needed to decide before listening. And somewhere in Winnipeg, Leonard Katz was preparing a lecture entitled Silence: The Final Frequency They Don’t Want You to Discover.
Tickets were $45.
Students $35.
Musicians free.